./doc/FAQ.sgml

Patch: TAG 0.7.4

+- <!doctype linuxdoc system>
+-
+- <article>
+-
+- 
+-
+- <title>Frox FAQ</title>
+- <author>
+- <name>James Hollingshead <tt/<frox at hollo.org/>
+- </author>
+- <date>2001/12/09</date>
+-
+- <abstract>
+- </abstract>
+-
+- 
+- <toc>
+-
+- 
+-
+- <sect>
+- <heading>General</heading>
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>What is frox?</heading>
+-
+- Frox is a transparent ftp proxy for linux written under
+- the GPL.
+- </sect1>
+-
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>What can it do for me?</heading>
+-
+- It will transparently proxy your ftp clients (duh). This
+- means that any clients you have that are behind the proxy will
+- believe that they are connecting to an ftp server as normal,
+- but will actually be connecting to frox. Frox will do the
+- onward connection to the remote server.
+-
+- It can also be set up to do non-transparent proxying. In
+- this case the ftp client can connect directly to frox, but
+- instead of logging in with ``username'' should log in with
+- ``username@ftp.wherever.org''.
+-
+- On either of these sorts of connections it can do caching
+- of files you download, or
+- converting of data connections from active-->passive which
+- can make firewalling rules a lot easier/safer. There is also
+- basic support for running a virus scanner on downloaded
+- files.
+-
+- These extra options can all be enabled/disabled at compile
+- time so if you don't want them you can still have a small
+- binary - the default one is around 30K.
+- </sect1>
+-
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>What can't it do for me?</heading>
+-
+- It does not implement ftp proxy over HTTP. This means if
+- you configure a web browser (eg. Netscape/Mozilla/IE) to use
+- frox as their ftp proxy it won't work. If you leave them with
+- ftp-proxy unconfigured then they should be transparently
+- proxied like anything else.
+-
+- IPv6 is completely unimplemented
+- </sect1>
+-
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>Why doesn't it run on ... OS</heading>
+-
+- Transparent proxy system calls vary a lot from system to
+- system. I only have success reports for linux and FreeBSD, but
+- you may well have success on any UNIX like OS which uses
+- ipfilter. See the section on <ref id="otheros"
+- name="systems other than linux"> for details and let me know if
+- you have success or failure
+- </sect1>
+-
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>Where can I get it?</heading>
+-
+- Latest versions should be downloadable from the homepage
+- at: <url url="http://frox.sourceforge.net/"> or at; <url
+- url="http://www.hollo.org/frox/">.
+- </sect1>
+- </sect>
+-
+- <sect>
+- <heading>Compiling and installing</heading>
+-
+- Compile frox with:
+- <tscreen><verb>
+- ./configure
+- make
+- make install (as root)
+- </verb></tscreen>
+-
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>./configure options</heading>
+-
+- 
+- <itemize>
+- <item> <tt>--enable-http-cache</tt> and
+- <tt>--enable-local-cache</tt> compile in caching support.
+- You can give both these options if you wish.</item>
+-
+- <item> <tt>--enable-virus-scan</tt> compiles in support
+- for virus scanning downloaded files.</item>
+-
+- <item> <tt>--enable-configfile=...</tt> allows you to set
+- the default config file to something else eg.
+- /etc/frox.conf. Otherwise it defaults to
+- /usr/local/etc/frox.conf</item>
+-
+- <item> <tt>--enable-transparent-data</tt> compiles in
+- support for transparently proxying the data connections.
+- Note you probably don't need this. Transparent proxying
+- works without, and it entails security risks. If you wish
+- to run on a 2.4.x kernel you will also need
+- <tt>--enable-libiptc</tt></item>
+-
+- </itemize>
+- 
+- </sect1>
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>Systems other than linux<label id="otheros"></heading>
+-
+- Frox was originally written for linux, but thanks to some
+- work by Sergey Matveychuk it should now run on BSD and
+- possibly some other UNIX like OSes. The configure script
+- should do things automatically for bsd systems, but their are
+- still one or two things you should be aware of.
+-
+- The BSD transparent proxying code can use ipfilter or ipfw.
+- ipfw is the default, but you can use the ipfilter code by
+- compiling with --enable-ipfilter. Other OSes which run ipfilter
+- may also work in this way. If you try it could you drop me an
+- email and let me know the result.
+-
+- You need to have <tt>Listen</tt> defined to a local IP address
+- in your config file if you are doing transparent proxying. This
+- means that you can't listen on more than one interface.
+-
+- You should also note that the TransparentData config file
+- option and the --enable-transparent-data compile time option
+- only works under linux. You probably don't need this
+- functionality anyway, but if you really do then feel free to
+- send me a patch. :)
+- </sect1>
+- </sect>
+-
+- <sect>
+- <heading>Configuration</heading>
+-
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>Configuring frox</heading>
+-
+- By default frox uses
+- <tt>/usr/local/etc/frox.conf</tt> as a configuration file, but
+- this can be changed either by giving
+- <tt>--enable-configfile=/etc/whatever/you/want</tt> to the
+- <tt>./configure</tt> script, or by the <tt/-f/ command line
+- option.
+-
+- The sample config file is well commented and the best
+- documentation for configuration. Note you will need to edit
+- some of these options for it to work at all. You will also need
+- to create a working directory for frox - see below.
+-
+- For the transparent proxying to work your kernel will need
+- to be compiled with transparent proxy support and you will need
+- to enable forwarding with ``<tt>echo 1 >>
+- /proc/sys/net/ipv4/ip_forward</tt>''. You then need to
+- redirect ftp requests passing through the box to frox. For
+- kernel 2.2 this will be something like ``<tt>ipchains -A input
+- -p tcp -s LOCALNET -d 0/0 21 -j REDIRECT 2121</tt>'', and for
+- kernel 2.4, ``<tt>iptables -t nat -A PREROUTING -p tcp -s
+- LOCALNET --dport 21 -j REDIRECT --to 2121</tt>''.
+-
+- You can configure frox to run from inetd with the FromInetd
+- option. This will not work well with either the local caching
+- or with TransparentData, but otherwise should be ok.
+-
+- </sect1>
+-
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>The Working Directory</heading>
+-
+- Frox needs a working directory, specified in the config
+- file. This is used for temporary files and sockets, for
+- creating cache files in, and is also the directory frox will
+- chroot to. This directory should be owned by root,
+- permissions 0755, and frox will create the directory
+- structure it needs in here. If you are doing virus scanning
+- or using the command control program then these binaries,
+- with any libraries they need, must also be added to this
+- directory.
+-
+- You may also have problems with resolving host names.
+- Frox needs to resolve host names if you are using non
+- transparent proxying, or if you are doing caching with
+- CacheOnFQDN set to yes. There are two ways to fix this:
+-
+- The quick and easy way is to define
+- <tt>ResolvLoadHack</tt> in the config file to an address
+- which is not defined in <tt>/etc/hosts</tt>. Frox will try
+- and resolve this on startup and this will load the relevant
+- resolver libraries. It doesn't matter if this address fails
+- to resolve.
+-
+- The other solution is to copy the resolver libraries into
+- the chroot jail. For me it works with <tt>host.conf</tt> and
+- <tt>resolv.conf</tt> in <tt>WorkingDir/etc/</tt>,
+- and <tt>libnss_dns.so.2</tt> and <tt>libresolv.so.2</tt> in
+- <tt>WorkingDir/lib/</tt> 
+- </sect1>
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>How should I configure my ftp clients?<label
+- id="client-ref"></heading>
+-
+- Normally you don't have to. Certainly don't set the ftp
+- proxy variable in your browser or set your ftp_proxy
+- environment variable to http://anything.
+-
+- If you are using non-transparent ftp proxying (set
+- ``DoNTP'' to ``yes'' in the config file) and you have a ftp
+- client which supports this (such as ncftp, or debian's apt-get
+- ftp method) then you need to set it up to login with
+- ``username@host[:port]''. eg. ``anonymous@ftp.gnu.org'' or
+- ``anonymous@ftp.gnu.org:21''. You can of course do this
+- manually by typing this in when prompted for the username.
+-
+- You may have a mixture of clients being transparently
+- proxied and clients being non transparently proxied. In this
+- case if you set the NTPAddress to the address/port you have
+- told your non transparently proxied clients to contact the
+- proxy on then only they will see frox's login banner. Clients
+- which are transparently redirected to frox will see the login
+- banner of the remote host they are contacting and will not be
+- offered the chance to login with username@host:port.
+-
+- </sect1>
+- </sect>
+-
+- <sect>
+- <heading>Caching</heading>
+-
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>HTTP caching vs local caching</heading>
+-
+- With HTTP caching frox rewrites ftp retrieve requests in
+- HTTP and sends them to a proxy server like squid which
+- actually retrieves the file and does the caching. With local
+- caching frox maintains its own cache of recently downloaded
+- files on the hard disk.
+-
+- The main advantage of the HTTP method is that the cache can
+- be shared with any web browsers which use the same proxy
+- directly for their ftp requests. Local caching is much faster
+- (especially for small files) and lighter on network
+- resources.
+-
+- Caching needs to be compiled in by running
+- <tt>./configure</tt> with <tt/--enable-http-cache/ or
+- <tt/--enable-local-cache/. You can have both compiled in if
+- you want - the cache method actually used (if any) is chosen
+- in the config file.
+-
+- For HTTP caching your config file needs to say:
+- <tscreen><verb>
+- CacheModule HTTP
+- HTTPProxy 192.168.2.1:3128 # proxy address
+- # and optionally...
+- MinCacheSize 64000 # in bytes
+- </verb></tscreen>
+-
+- Files smaller than MinCacheSize will not be cached. Latency
+- on small files can be really bad with this method since the
+- HTTP proxy has to make a separate connection to the ftp server
+- - setting MinCacheSize fairly high will help with this.
+-
+- For Local caching your config file should say:<tscreen><verb>
+- CacheModule Local
+- # and optionally...
+- CacheSize 100 # in MB
+- </verb></tscreen>
+-
+- The cached copies will be created within frox's working directory
+- as specified in the config file. If CacheSize is unspecified the
+- cache will grow indefinitely.
+- </sect1>
+-
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>StrictCaching</heading>
+-
+- With strict caching off frox works out the URI for the file
+- it is retrieving by sending a PWD to ask the server what
+- the current working directory is. On a small minority of
+- servers this may be broken, and a server may return the same
+- answer to PWD for more than one directory. If additionally two
+- such directories contain files with the same names, sizes, and
+- times of modification then frox could cache the wrong file by
+- mistake.
+-
+- StrictCaching tries to get around this by keeping track of
+- all directory changes and making up its own path instead of
+- asking the server for it. This has the disadvantage that ``cd
+- pub; get readme'' will not cache to the same file as ``get
+- pub/readme'' or ``get /pub/readme'' or ``cd /pub; get
+- readme''. As a result your cache hit rate will probably drop
+- considerably, but you will have the extra security. Note that
+- you can set this on a per server basis if there is a
+- particular server about which you are worried.
+-
+- Thanks to Henrik Nordstrom for pointing this problem out
+- and suggesting a solution.
+- </sect1>
+-
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>CacheOnFQDN</heading>
+-
+- This option involves using FQDNs instead of IP addresses
+- for the cache requests (either to squid or the local cache),
+- and allowing squid to guess whether to
+- use binary or ascii file transfer rather than using the value
+- supplied by the ftp client. For transparently proxied
+- connections this requires a reverse DNS lookup to get the
+- FQDN, and may cause problems with un-synced mirrored ftp hosts
+- all running off the same FQDN, although most of the time there
+- will be no problems. The advantage is that you should increase
+- the hit rate, in particular with squid based caching for files
+- which have been previously downloaded through squid with a web
+- browser.
+-
+- If all your clients are being non transparently proxied
+- then this option should cause no problems. Otherwise use with some care,
+- although it may be worth the extra hit rate.
+- </sect1>
+-
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>I get an ``Unable to initialise cache'' error.</heading>
+-
+- Check that frox was compiled with support for the cache
+- module you are attempting to use, and that you have given the
+- correct Cache options for that module. If doing http caching check
+- that the http proxy name resolves.
+- </sect1>
+-
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>I retrieved a file I had retrieved before and it doesn't
+- seem to have been cached?</heading>
+-
+- Files are not cached for non-anonymous ftp sessions, or if
+- the ftp server doesn't support the MDTM and SIZE extensions.
+- Additionally if the host's DNS name resolves to more than one
+- IP address then the file will be cached, but frox has no way
+- of knowing that the different IP addresses refer to the same
+- host - unless your ftp client happens to pick the same IP both
+- times you will not get the cached file back. Using CacheOnFQDN
+- may impove this behaviour.
+- </sect1>
+- </sect>
+-
+- <sect>
+- <heading>Virus scanning</heading>
+-
+- You can configure frox to run a virus scanner on downloaded
+- files between downloading them to the proxy and them being
+- forwarded to the client. You need to <tt>./configure</tt> with
+- <tt>--enable-virus-scan</tt>, and set the config file variable
+- VirusScanner to something like <tt>
+- '"/usr/local/bin/yourviruscanner"
+- "--options" "&percnt;s"'</tt>. You no
+- longer need to be doing local caching for this to work - it
+- will work with caching through squid or with no caching at
+- all.
+-
+- Note that the whole variable is enclosed in single quotes
+- ('), while the individual arguments within are enclosed with
+- double quotes ("). The <tt>"&percnt;s"</tt>
+- will be replaced by the name of the file to scan. NB. unlike
+- all the other paths in the config file, any pathnames or
+- filenames in VirusScanner will not be stripped in the
+- case that you are running in a chroot jail. If your virus
+- scanner exits with a value other than 0 when a file is scanned
+- and is virus free you will need to set VSOK to that value.
+-
+- There are currently some problems with this:
+- <itemize>
+- <item>Only file downloads are scanned.</item>
+-
+- <item>If the file contains a virus then the file will
+- not be sent to the user, even if your virus scanner is
+- able to clean the virus from the file.</item>
+-
+- <item>The user will see a delay before the file starts
+- to download as the whole thing must be downloaded to
+- the proxy and be scanned before any of it can be
+- passed to the client.</item>
+-
+- </itemize>
+-
+- If the <tt>VSProgressMsgs</tt> option is set to something
+- other than <tt>0</tt> then every time that number of seconds
+- passes during the delay a progress message will be sent to the
+- client. On the plus side these may be displayed to users of
+- command line ftp clients, and will probably prevent clients
+- from giving up and timing out. On the down side the progress
+- messages could confuse some ftp clients (I think they do with
+- some Mozilla builds).
+-
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>Can I redirect requests to a virus scanning http proxy?</heading>
+-
+- Probably not. Most of these proxies send various http progress
+- messages back to the client. Frox is unable to parse these without
+- giving it a more extensive http implementation, and so it will
+- probably fail. Also there will be a delay before the client starts
+- to get the file, and it may well time out during this period. There
+- is interest in being able to do this though, so if anyone wants to
+- try coding it then they are welcome.
+- </sect>
+-
+- <sect>
+- <heading>Security</heading>
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>User, Group and Chroot</heading>
+-
+- Unless compiled with --enable-run-as-root you must specify
+- a non root user and group for frox to run as. It is strongly
+- recommended that you do this rather than recompiling.
+-
+- You must specify WorkingDir for frox in the config file. By
+- default it will also chroot to this directory. If you do not
+- wish to run chrooted you must explicitly set DontChroot to "yes"
+- in the config file.
+- </sect1>
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>Access control lists</heading>
+-
+- Access to frox is controlled by the access control lists in
+- the config file. These take the format
+- <verb>
+- ACL ACTION CLIENT - SERVER [PORTS]
+- </verb>
+- <tt>ACTION</tt> can be one of <tt>Deny</tt> or <tt>Allow</tt>.
+- <tt>CLIENT</tt> and <tt>SERVER</tt> are either a domain name,
+- a <tt>*</tt>, an ip address, or an address/netmask in either
+- <tt>x.x.x.x/y</tt> or <tt>x.x.x.x/y.y.y.y</tt> form.
+- <tt>PORTS</tt> is optional. If present it should contain one
+- or more port numbers or ranges of port numbers, separated by
+- &dquot;,&dquot;. There should be no whitespace within the
+- <tt>PORTS</tt> string. If no ports are specified then ports
+- are not taken into account in matching that rule.
+-
+- Acls are checked after the client has connected to frox,
+- but before frox connects to the server. If non-transparent
+- proxying is enabled then the client will enter the username
+- before the acl is checked. The acls are checked in the order
+- they appear in the config file until one matches. If no acls
+- match the connection is denied.
+- </sect1>
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>Command Control Program</heading>
+-
+- Frox has optional support for a ftp-proxy like command
+- control program (ccp). Just to confuse things there are two
+- different ways that this can work. The default is still the
+- old version based on ftp-proxy, while the new version is a bit
+- more like the squid redirector interface.
+-
+- To use either method you should compile with
+- <tt>--enable-ccp</tt>, and set <tt>CCProgram</tt> to the
+- program you wish use. This must be within the chroot jail with
+- any libraries and/or shells it needs to run. To use the new
+- version you should also explicitly set <tt>UseOldCCP</tt> to
+- <tt>no</tt> in the config file.
+-
+- <sect2>
+- <heading>The Old Version</heading>
+-
+- The ccp will then be called for every command that the
+- client sends. It will not be called for any commands that
+- frox decides to send itself (eg. as part of determining
+- whether a file is suitable for caching). It can make use of
+- the following environment variables:
+- <verb>
+- FROX_CLIENT, FROX_SERVER: Ip addresses of client and server.
+- FROX_SERVERNAME: Server's domain name if known.
+- FROX_SESSION: Unique string for this session.
+- FROX_COMMAND: FTP command just given.
+- FROX_PARAMATER: Argument to that command.
+- </verb>
+- With a new connection the ccp will be called with the
+- special <tt>FROX_COMMAND</tt> of <tt>+NEW</tt>. The server
+- variables may subsequently change if a user name is given
+- which contains a different server to contact.
+-
+- If the ccp exits with a value of 0 then the command is
+- dealt with as normal. If it exits with 1 then the command is
+- discarded. If it exits with 2 then the session is closed. If
+- the ccp writes a line to stderr then it will be sent to the
+- client over the control connection. If it writes a line to
+- stdout it will be logged by frox. If the ccp returns a value
+- other than 0 it is its responsibility to write a well formed
+- ftp message to the client which tells it what is happening
+- (eg. from a shell script by echo -ne "533 Permission
+- denied\r\n" >&2) . Failure to do this will result in
+- the client and proxy getting out of sync.
+- </sect2>
+- <sect2>
+- <heading>The New Version</heading>
+-
+- One copy of the ccp will be executed each time a client
+- connects. It should read commands and messages from
+- <tt>stdin</tt> and write it's replies back to
+- <tt>stdout</tt>. Each call is a '\n' terminated string which
+- starts with a single char, followed optionally by a space
+- and a string.
+-
+- If the initial char is "I" then it is followed by
+- <tt>&dquot;client_ip server_ip server_name&dquot;</tt>,
+- although if the server_name is not known it will be replaced
+- by an "X". If the char is a "C" then it is followed by a
+- command from the client, and if it is a "S" it is followed
+- by a message from the server.
+-
+- The ccp should reply with a similar string. "C" should be
+- followed by a message to go the client, while S is followed
+- by a command for the server. In response to an "I" a "R" can
+- be sent where the argument is the IP address of a server to
+- contact in place of the currently selected one. A single "X"
+- tells frox to continue as before, while a "Q" tells frox to
+- drop the connection. Finally the string after an "L" will be
+- logged by frox. It should also be followed by another line
+- giving an action to take.
+-
+- Written like that is is pretty confusing, so there are
+- two example ccp scripts in the doc/ directory. One is a
+- simple bash script to disallow downloading of files greater
+- than a certain size. The other is a more complicated C
+- program which attempts to redirect users to mirrors of ftp
+- sites. I am sure there are other applications.
+- </sect2>
+- </sect1>
+- </sect>
+- <sect>
+- <heading>Troubleshooting</heading>
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>I can't connect to an ftp site through frox?</heading>
+-
+- Look at the log file that frox produces and see if it gives
+- you any clues. It should say ``Connect from A to B''. If it
+- doesn't say anything then you aren't getting through to frox
+- at all - check the config file to see frox is listening on the
+- right address/interface. Have you remembered to do the
+- ipchains/iptables command that is in the INSTALL file?
+-
+- If the log file suggests frox is connecting back to itself
+- then you are probably contacting it directly and
+- non-transparent proxying is switched off. Either switch
+- non-transparent proxying on in the config file, or make sure
+- that your ftp client is not trying to connect directly to frox
+- - either from you specifying the frox machine as the ftp host
+- on the command line, or from the client trying to use it
+- explicitly as a proxy.
+-
+- If you have a complicated network setup then check the<ref
+- id="networking" name="Network Problems"> section. 
+-
+- Read the <ref id="client-ref" name="client configuration">
+- section again
+- </sect1>
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>Non transparent proxying won't work</heading>
+-
+- Check whether you have NTPAddress set. If this is set then
+- it must be set to the address and port that the ftp clients
+- are using to contact the proxy, otherwise clients will not be
+- offered non transparent proxying. If you unset it then all
+- clients will be offered non transparent proxying.
+- </sect1>
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>Frox ignores the Squid proxy I am using</heading>
+-
+- If you have HTTP caching set up then frox should conduct
+- all anonymous downloads through your proxy. But, frox also
+- needs to make an ftp connection to the remote ftp server for
+- retrieving directory listings etc. Therefore if you do netstat
+- or equivalent you will not see a connection from frox to squid
+- unless a file download is actually in progress.
+-
+- This also means that you cannot use frox + squid and then
+- firewall off ftp access to the outside world altogether. Your
+- best bet is to keep frox (with or without squid), and set
+- <tt>ApConv</tt> to <tt>yes</tt> in the config file. You will
+- still need to allow frox to make outbound tcp connections on
+- port 21, and any ports in the PasvPorts range, but you should
+- not have any of the usual problems associated with firewalling
+- ftp.
+- </sect1>
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>Audiogalaxy</heading>
+-
+- Audiogalaxy is a music sharing program. Although
+- audiogalaxy works through port 21 it does not use the ftp
+- protocol, and therefore frox does not allow its connections
+- through. If you are using frox as a transparent proxy and you
+- wish to use audiogalaxy then you need to change your
+- iptables/netfilter rules so that packets addressed to the
+- audiogalaxy servers do not pass through frox. Fortunately
+- audiogalaxy does not use port 21 to contact other machines
+- using the audiogalaxy client so these do not also need to be
+- added.
+- </sect1>
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>I still can't get it to work</heading>
+-
+- Feel free to drop me a line at <tt/frox at hollo.org/.
+- Please let me know what version of frox you are running, what
+- version of the linux kernel, whether you gave any options to
+- <tt>./configure</tt> at compile time, and what point exactly
+- it fails at. The log file should give you some info, and if
+- you are feeling brave you could recompile with the
+- <tt/--enable-debug/ option to <tt>./configure</tt> and the log
+- file will give you lots of information.
+- </sect1>
+- </sect>
+- <sect>
+- <heading>Network problems<label id="networking"></heading>
+-
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>General</heading>
+-
+- If you are running frox on a machine on your default route,
+- and with little or no firewalling between it and either the
+- outside world or your internal network you should not have
+- network problems. Because of the nature of the ftp protocol
+- though, if your setup is more complicated than this then you
+- may run into difficulties.
+-
+- The easiest way of checking that your network setup isn't
+- what is causing the problems is to (temporarily if you wish)
+- run an ftp server on the machine which runs frox. If you can't
+- ftp from your clients to this server and retrieve files O.K.
+- then your clients won't be able to ftp to frox either. Also
+- try running an ftp client on the frox machine and connecting
+- to a server in the outside world. If this doesn't work then
+- frox obviously won't be able to do this either.
+- </sect1>
+-
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>Control connection problems</heading>
+-
+- With a control connection problem your clients will not be
+- able to connect to ftp servers through frox at all. If
+- transparently proxying then check that
+- outgoing tcp traffic is being redirected to frox without
+- changing the destination address (ie. you must route it there,
+- not use DNAT), and that the machine running frox can make a
+- tcp connection to the outside world successfully
+- </sect1>
+- <sect1>
+- <heading>Data connection problems</heading>
+-
+- If the problem is with the data connection then your
+- clients will be able to connect to the ftp server, login, and
+- do things like print the current working directory. File
+- retrievals and directory listings will fail, though you may
+- find that passive mode ftp works and active doesn't, or visa
+- versa.
+-
+- If you are having these problems I strongly reccomend that
+- you set <tt>TransparentData</tt> to <tt>no</tt>, and
+- <tt>ApConv</tt> to <tt>yes</tt> in the config file. The frox
+- machine must be able to make tcp connections on any port to
+- the outside world. It should also be possible to establish tcp
+- connections in either direction between the frox machine and
+- the client machines, and with no NAT being performed on these
+- connections. With this setup you shouldn't have any
+- problems.
+-
+- The above suggestions aren't strictly necessary, but things
+- get more complicated without them.
+- <itemize>
+- <item><tt>ApConv</tt> = <tt>no</tt>: Either incoming tcp
+- connections must be allowed from the outside world to the
+- machine running frox, or they must be prevented only by a
+- NATed (IP masquerading) firewall which is configured to
+- allow ftp connections (eg. linux + ipt_nat_ftp.o
+- module)</item>
+-
+- <item>If frox cannot make tcp connections to the client then
+- clients are limited to passive mode ftp.</item>
+-
+- <item>If clients cannot make arbitrary tcp connections to
+- frox then they are limited to active mode ftp.</item>
+-
+- <item>NAT between client and frox: If DNAT occurs when the
+- client connects to frox (ie. the client makes the connection
+- to a different IP to that which the packets frox eventually
+- receives are addressed to then you should set
+- <tt>PASVAddress</tt> to the IP which the clients should use.
+- NB. This option doesn't actually exist yet, but let me know
+- if you need it and I'll consider adding it.</item>
+-
+- <item><tt>TransparentData</tt> = <tt>yes</tt>: This can make
+- things really unpleasant. Are you sure you need
+- it? These are the problems which spring to mind...
+- <itemize>
+- <item>Frox should be in your default route for outgoing
+- tcp traffic. If you are using policy based routing to
+- route only port 21 tcp traffic to frox then
+- TransparentData will not work.</item>
+-
+- <item>Beware that frox will make connections to your
+- clients that purport to be from arbitrary hosts outside
+- your network. If there is a firewall/router between your
+- frox and your clients with IP spoofing protection it must
+- let these packets through.</item>
+-
+- <item>Have another read of SECURITY to remind yourself of
+- the extra risks you are taking.</item>
+- </itemize>
+- </item>
+-
+- </itemize>
+- </sect1>
+- </sect>
+- </article>
+-

Previous patch

Home

Next patch

./doc/FAQ.sgml

Patch: TAG 0.7.4